West Hollywood Drops LGBTQ Requirement for $1,000 a Month ‘Guaranteed Income’ Program Over Lawsuit Concerns
West Hollywood has dropped the requirement for applicants to be LGBTQ for their $1,000 a month guaranteed income pilot program.
Officials feared that they would face lawsuits for violating the California constitution.
The City Council is meeting on Monday to go over a revised plan for the program that will give out $1,000 a month, no strings-attached, to seniors who meet income and age criteria. The program was originally only going to offer the free cash to people who do not identify as straight.
A city staff report obtained by local website WeHoville read as follows:
In March 2022, the City became aware that the pilot, as it was created and supported by a government entity, was susceptible to legal challenges due to the inclusion of LGBTQIA criteria as an eligibility requirement to participate. Although the City could engage in a legal battle over the contested eligibility requirement, the implications of litigating such a challenge had to be considered.
Having LGBTQIA identification as an eligibility requirement for the pilot could potentially violate the California Constitution as sexual orientation is a protected suspect class in our state. This means that when a law or government-funded program treats persons differently based on sexual orientation, those laws and program are subject to an exacting standard known as strict scrutiny (even if the law is intended to benefit that protected suspect class). Guaranteed income is an emerging area of policy making, with many nuanced components, and there is no direct case law on this issue. However, based on analogous legal situations, negative and unintended outcomes from litigation are probable. On a community level, a decision to engage in a legal battle could have the additional unintended consequence of causing harm to the community members the pilot was created to support.
Therefore, the City Attorney, City staff and pilot partners recommend that the City Council revise the pilot to include three of the four original criteria (residency, age and income level) in order to satisfy the legal obligations, protect potential participants, and move forward with a program that serves community members in need of financial support and stability.
With tremendous collective frustration and disappointment that we are unable to advance the original pilot, City staff and partners are suggesting a modified path forward: to move forward with a revised pilot designed for older adult West Hollywood community members living on a low income.
Go to Source
Author: Cassandra Fairbanks